The YouTuber-turned-fighter's jaw dropped agape, his eyes becoming wide, stunned circles as he collapsed to the mat in shock and awe following a devastating right hand from Anthony Joshua. It looked as if Paul was trying to utter "Wow!" as the force of the impact sank in to his scrambled senses.
"The fans didn't spend money to see this rubbish," said the referee, summing up the sorry affair far more succinctly than anyone else could.
Trapped in a neutral corner of the ring midway through the sixth round, Paul could not run or hold on to Joshua's legs in a desperate clinch as the serious reality of the sweet science enveloped him. Instead, as he attempted to withstand the shot that broke his jaw in two distinct locations, Paul was lost in an completely dazed moment.
So this is how it feels, and looks, to be struck cleanly by a real professional fighter, an Olympic gold medallist and ex- world heavyweight champion. "Wow" is indeed the appropriate term.
It was the fourth time the social media star had been sent to the floor, but the result of a clean power shot meant Paul could not get up and taunt his opponent before the referee waved the contest to a halt. As blood began to leak from his mouth, and a dull ache radiated through his jaw, Paul at last understood how hard, grueling, and dangerous boxing is at a decent standard of professionalism.
Anthony Joshua, it should be stressed, was not impressive amid the bedlam. After his hollow victory, he made a throat-slitting gesture that suggested a clinical and deadly execution when, in reality, Joshua had cut a frustrated figure for most of the fight. Rather than glowering with menace or exhibiting an iron certainty, Joshua had appeared hesitant and crude for almost five stanzas.
Paul's poor fitness, which is a fundamental requirement in top-level boxing, dictated the result. Without the gas to escape any longer, and resorting to falling to the canvas as frequently as he could for a rest, Paul was left defenseless by fatigue. Joshua applied the brutal ending, but, up to that point, he had looked like a mournful shadow of the fighter he was in 2017.
"That was not the best display," Joshua admitted. "The end goal was to catch Jake Paul, pin him down and hurt him. That has been the plan, and that's what was on my thoughts. It took a bit longer than anticipated, but the right hand finally found its destination."
Joshua commended Paul's bravery but he added an explanation for his own stilted performance. "He faced a real fighter tonight that's had a fifteen-month hiatus," Joshua said, referencing his previous loss. "We shook off the cobwebs, and I can't wait to head into 2026."
In the press conference afterwards, a jovial Joshua tried out a woeful imitation of his domestic rival as he called for a fight against the currently retired boxer. Joshua will likely get his wish, but that matchup comes far too late in their careers. Both men are on the downward slope of the peak.
In contrast, the most interesting big men in the world are the Ukrainian master and Moses Itauma. Usyk remains the unquestioned king of the division, after defeating both Joshua and Fury on two occasions. At the same time, Itauma is a rapidly ascending force. The young British heavyweight would probably have needed fewer than half the number of three-minute periods that Joshua required to send Paul into a appropriately astonished state.
But the fans receives what the public wants, and that certainly means additional pitiful crossover contests. Paul appeared genuinely satisfied and cocky to have had his jaw broken by a hammer-like right. In the early hours of Saturday morning, he shared an X-ray, with the pair of breaks marked in crimson.
That jokey reference to SaĆŗl "Canelo" Ćlvarez, a far greater boxer than Joshua but a equally diminished force, demonstrated that Paul's brazen audacity remains undented. It may not be Canelo, but Paul will soon locate someone else with whom he can make more than $50 million.
While he was being interviewed, before departing to the medical facility, Paul spat a streak of blood onto the canvas. It was one more grim symbol of the night as Paul mixed blunt truth with blood-flecked bullshit and said: "I think my jaw is broken. It's definitely broke. A proper beating from one of the best to ever step in the ring. I love this sport and I'm going to return and keep on winning."
A seasoned journalist with over a decade of experience covering UK politics and social issues, known for insightful analysis.